8 Places Like Bora Bora (We’ve Been to All of Them)

by Nichole | Last updated Oct 23, 2026 | Maldives

Our overwater bungalow in Bora Bora had a glass coffee table that slid open, so we could watch the fish and rays right below us. That's the bar every place on this list has to clear.

My husband and I have been to every destination below, and we spent our own vacation days on each one. No single place matched Bora Bora on everything. Moorea comes closest, and the Maldives beats it on beaches.

I scored each place against the five things that made Bora Bora special for us, so you can pick by whatever matters most to you.

This post may contain affiliate links. If you purchase through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only recommend places and products I’ve tried myself.

In This Post

What Makes Bora Bora Special

InterContinental Le Moana Bora Bora Beach at sunset

Where we stayed: InterContinental Le Moana Bora Bora Beach at sunset

These are the five things that made Bora Bora stand out for us:

✔️ Great beaches

✔️ Turquoise, clear water

✔️ Overwater villas

✔️ Exceptional snorkeling (see my snorkeling tour review)

✔️ Dramatic landscape

For snorkeling, a place only gets the check if we swam a site there that earned five masks on my snorkel scale, the same score I gave Bora Bora.

A place doesn't need all five to be worth the trip. Under each one, I list what it matches and where it falls short.

The Short Answer

  • Closest match on all five: Moorea, a 30-minute ferry from Tahiti.
  • Overwater villa plus better beaches: the Maldives. It's flat, but the sand beats Bora Bora's.
  • Big scenery and some of the most beautiful beaches we've stood on: the Seychelles. No overwater villas, and the snorkeling is weaker.
  • Mountains without a passport: Maui.
  • Shorter flight with an overwater option: St. Lucia for the peaks, Aruba for calm water, Belize for the reef.

How the Alternatives Stack Up

PlaceGreat beachesTurquoise waterOverwater villasTop snorkelingDramatic views
MooreaYesYesYesYesYes
The MaldivesYesYesYesYesNo
St. LuciaYesYesYesone resortNoYes
MauiYesYesNoYesYes
The SeychellesYesYesNoNoYes
Taha'aNoYesYesone resortYesYes
ArubaYesYesYesone resortNoNo
BelizeNoYesYesone villaYesNo

1. Moorea: The Closest Match

Snorkeling at Sofitel Moorea

Sofitel overwater villas in Moorea 

BEST FOR: travelers who want Bora Bora's peaks and lagoon and like to rent a car and explore.

SKIP IT IF: you want to land, check in and never leave the resort.

Matches Bora Bora on: all five

Moorea is the only place on this list that checks every box, and it's where I'd send most people first. It's a 30-minute ferry from Tahiti, so you skip the domestic flight Bora Bora needs.

We spent two weeks hopping between Moorea, Taha'a, Bora Bora and Rangiroa, and here's the full 2-week French Polynesia itinerary.

The landscape is the big draw. The view from the top of Magic Mountain over Opunohu Bay was worth the steep climb and the screaming muscles afterward. Temae Beach, next to the Sofitel, gave us white sand and clear water with mountains behind the palms.

The snorkeling holds its own. On our Alex Lagoon Tours day, we stood in chest-deep water while curious blacktip reef sharks swam close and stingrays nosed at us like puppies.

See all the sites in my Moorea snorkeling guide.

We rented a car and stayed six nights in a waterfront rental. Every night we watched the sky keep changing color for a good 20 minutes after the sun went down. The overwater bungalows are at the Sofitel and the Hilton.

Not everything delivered. The reef by the Hilton was disappointing on a choppy day, after everything I'd read promised more, and we missed the humpback whales by visiting in early June.

Skip Moorea if you want to land, check in and never leave the resort. The island rewards people who rent a car and explore.

2. Maldives: Better Beaches, No Mountains

Private pool in overwater villa at Outrigger Maafushivaru Maldives Resort

Outrigger Maldives Maafushivaru: Our Overwater Villa with Pool

BEST FOR: an overwater villa, soft white sand and a house reef you can swim from your resort.

SKIP IT IF: you like to explore by car and eat at roadside snack shacks

The Maldives is the closest match for the overwater part of Bora Bora, and the beaches are better. The sand at all three Maldives resorts we stayed at was clearly softer and whiter.

The snorkeling is as good as Bora Bora's if you pick the right island. At the Outrigger Maafushivaru, we swam with blacktip reef sharks on the house reef and slept in an overwater villa with its own pool.

Here are the six house reefs I'd choose from.

The landscape is what's missing. From the seaplane, the islands looked like little frisbees floating on the water, with no mountain anywhere. Most resorts sit on their own island, so you eat and drink where you sleep, at resort prices, and you can't bring your own alcohol.

It's also a long haul, around 24 hours from the US East Coast. I compare the two head to head in Bora Bora vs. the Maldives.

3. St. Lucia: Peaks Plus an Overwater Option

St Lucia and view of Pitons mountains

View of the towering Pitons mountains in St. Lucia

BEST FOR: hikers who want dramatic peaks on a Caribbean trip.

SKIP IT IF: you want a flat, lazy beach week.

St. Lucia is on this list for the Pitons, two steep peaks on the southwest coast that give it a skyline in the same spirit as Bora Bora's.

My husband and I hiked Gros Piton, and it was one of the hardest hikes I’ve ever done. It’s much shorter than our hike to Base de las Torres in Chile’s Patagonia, but my legs felt just as wrecked afterward.

I couldn’t sit comfortably for days, but the view from the top was worth it.

The water and beaches are beautiful, but we didn’t find any great snorkeling. The island’s only overwater bungalows are at one adults-only all-inclusive resort.

4. Maui: Mountains Without a Passport

Secret Beach at Makena Cove in Maui

Makena Cove, Maui 

BEST FOR: mountains and clear water without needing a passport.

SKIP IT IF: you really want to be off the grid. Maui is more developed than most of the other islands on this list. It even has a Costco.

Maui has the mountains and the clear water, and it means a lot to us.

My husband and I got married on a small beach at Makena Cove with our immediate family and a Hawaiian minister playing the ukulele. We've been to four of the Hawaiian islands, and Maui looks the most like Bora Bora to me.

We loved the clear water at Black Rock and Honolua Bay for snorkeling. There are no overwater villas, and US citizens don't need a passport.

Maui is also more developed than most places on this list. Some people will see that as a plus, with more choices for where to stay and eat. Others will miss the small-island feel.

5. Seychelles: Beaches and Boulders

Stunning Anse Lazio in the Seychelles

Stunning Anse Lazio in the Seychelles

Best for: beach lovers with time for a long trip.

Skip it if: you only have a week. It's over 30 hours each way, plus a ferry or flight between islands.

The Seychelles has the drama Bora Bora has, in a different shape: huge granite boulders where Bora Bora has its volcanic peaks.

We spent our time on Praslin and La Digue, and the beaches were the reason we went.

Anse Georgette on Praslin is one of the most beautiful beaches I've ever stood on. The sand is fine as flour and sticks to everything, and the water was warm and clear. On La Digue we got around by bike, and from Praslin we took a boat to Curieuse Island to see the giant tortoises.

The snorkeling was decent, not exceptional. It didn't match the Maldives, Belize or French Polynesia, and rough seas kept us out of the water at several sites we'd planned to swim. There are no overwater villas, and it's over 30 hours from the US. Details in my Seychelles snorkeling guide.

We stayed in a rental on Praslin and at Le Nautique on La Digue, and we'd book both again.

6. Tahaa: The Quiet Neighbor

Snorkeling at the beautiful Coral Garden Tahaa

Coral Garden Tahaa

BEST FOR: a slow, quiet few days near Bora Bora, built around the Coral Garden drift snorkel.

SKIP IT IF: you want a lot to do. Beyond a few snorkel tours and a vanilla tour, that's about it.

Tahaa is the quiet one. You can't fly straight there, so we flew into Raiatea and took a 20-minute boat across. We stayed in a villa rental with a pool.

The Coral Garden drift snorkel is why most people come. You walk to the end of a little motu, slip in and let the current carry you over the coral in crystal clear water, like a giant slip 'n slide. It was so much fun we went back on our own for a second day.

The same tour took us to a vanilla plantation, a pearl farm and a rhum distillery, and we ate lunch at a picnic table set in the water while baby blacktip reef sharks swam past our feet.

The island's one overwater resort, Le Tahaa, sits on a small motu facing Bora Bora. We went for lunch but didn't stay.

What Tahaa doesn't have is great beaches. Come for the water and the views.

7. Aruba: Easy Flight From the U.S.

Arashi Beach in Aruba

Arashi Beach in Aruba

BEST FOR: calm water and an overwater option without a long-haul flight.

SKIP IT IF: you want the big wow factor. Next to every other place on this list, its landscape is pretty flat.

Aruba surprises people on this list. It's mostly flat, but the water is calm and clear, and it has an overwater resort a short flight from home.

The beaches are the big draw, and Aruba has some of the best in the world. In Tripadvisor's 2026 Travelers' Choice awards, Eagle Beach ranked No. 1 in the Caribbean and No. 4 in the world.

We've spent time on both Eagle Beach and Palm Beach. Eagle Beach is wide and relaxed, and its northern end has no beachfront hotels, so it felt much less crowded.

Palm Beach has super calm, turquoise water, but it gets extremely crowded, with chairs and umbrellas packed close together.

Here's how to choose between Eagle Beach and Palm Beach.

We've been several times and always stayed at the Boardwalk Boutique Hotel, an adults-only spot in a former coconut plantation a short walk from Palm Beach. Arashi Beach became one of our favorite spots.

The snorkeling is fun, not exceptional. We swam with turtles at Tres Trapi and snorkeled out past the reef cuts to a sunken tugboat at Mangel Halto.

8. Belize: For the Reef

Snorkeling with nurse sharks at Shark Ray Alley in Belize

Snorkeling with nurse sharks at Shark Ray Alley in Belize 

Best for: snorkelers who'd trade a perfect beach for one of the best reefs we've swum.

Skip it if: you want fine dining or all-inclusive pampering.

Belize earns its spot underwater. Ambergris Caye is the jumping-off point for the Belize Barrier Reef, which UNESCO calls the largest barrier reef in the Northern Hemisphere.

Our day at Shark Ray Alley, surrounded by nurse sharks and stingrays, earned an exceptional five masks on my snorkel scale.

We stayed on the south side of the island, at what's now the Alaia Belize, and got around by golf cart. The jerk chicken from a pimento-wood grill near our hotel is still one of the best meals we've had anywhere.

More in my San Pedro guide.

The beaches are the weak spot. If you want perfectly groomed, sugary sand, you'll be happier elsewhere. There's no mountain backdrop either, and the only overwater villa we know of is a single one on a private island.

Where We Splurged and Saved

Watching a seaplane takeoff at Reethi Faru Resort in the Maldives

Watching the seaplane from the pool at Reethi Faru Resort in the Maldives 

We paid resort prices for overwater villas four times: at the InterContinental Le Moana in Bora Bora, and at the Outrigger Maafushivaru, Reethi Faru and Le Meridien in the Maldives.

All four were worth the money. We watched fish through a glass coffee table at Le Moana, took outdoor showers over the water, and sat in our own plunge pool at the Outrigger while rays swam by.

Everywhere else, we skipped the splurge and found better value in boutique hotels and rentals.

In Moorea and Taha'a we rented houses and picked up groceries on the way from the ferry or boat.

In Aruba we stay at the Boardwalk.

In the Seychelles we rented a place on Praslin and stayed at Le Nautique, a small waterfront hotel on La Digue.

Even on a splurge, you can trim the bill in Bora Bora. We bought wine at a market on the main island instead of paying resort bar prices.

The Maldives works the other way. You can't shop off the resort or bring in your own alcohol, so every meal and drink is at resort prices. A cheaper nightly rate there can still cost more by checkout.

What I'd Tell a Friend

If you've never been to French Polynesia, don't let this list talk you out of Bora Bora. Go, and add Moorea. It's the one place that checks all five boxes, and renting a house there let us cook and explore on our own schedule.

If you've already done Bora Bora and want that feeling somewhere new, pick the checks that matter most to you.

Go to the Maldives for the overwater villa and the beaches, the Seychelles for scenery, or Belize if you're short on vacation days and the reef matters most.

Meet Nichole

Meet Nichole

Think of me as your geeky, discerning travel friend who dives deep (Google Page 20 and travel forums deep!) to find what’s really worth your vacation days.

My husband and I have explored 36 countries, from African safaris and 87 snorkel sites to boutique hotels and the world’s great wine regions. We both work full time, so every vacation day counts. From $2 street tacos to Michelin-starred dinners, we’re always chasing what’s worth the money.

If this sounds like you, subscribe below!

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Hi, I'm Nichole!

Snorkeling with sharks one day, a Michelin meal the next. I share first-hand guides to rated snorkel spots, African safaris, charming boutique hotels, and wine travel to help discerning travelers plan trips worth taking.

Enriching Pursuits Ladybug Logo

Sound like you?

Then you'll love my latest on:

  • Boutique Stays: charm and warm service
  • Sip & Savor: wine getaways & foodie finds
  • Outdoor Pursuits: snorkeling, hikes, bike trails
  • Nichole Pro Tips: save smart, splurge wisely