St. John is the smallest of the three main U.S. Virgin Islands, and we still ran out of days before we ran out of things to do.
We spent nine days there in December, based in a villa above Coral Bay, with a Jeep and no tours booked.
This is the list I'd hand a friend: what I'd do again, plus the couple of famous stops I'd skip. Snorkeling is a big part of it, but this isn't the snorkel guide.
For every site we swam, rated and mapped, see my St. John snorkeling guide.
For the day-by-day version, here's our full 9-day St. John itinerary.
This post may contain affiliate links. If you purchase through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only recommend places and products I’ve tried myself.
In This Post
The Short Version
- Only have 3-4 days: Waterlemon Cay in the morning, turtles at Francis Bay, one beach day at Trunk Bay, and lunch at Skinny Legs.
- Want to stay out of the water for a day: hike Ram Head early, then spend the afternoon on a villa balcony.
- Food on the Coral Bay side: Miss Lucy's for the grouper Reuben, Skinny Legs for a burger and a Painkiller.
- Food in Cruz Bay: North Shore Deli before a North Shore beach day, Shaibu's for something lighter.
- What I'd skip: the Trunk Bay snorkel trail if you're short on time, and the spur trail off Blue Cobblestone Beach on the way to Ram Head.
1. Snorkel Waterlemon Cay
Waterlemon Cay in St. John USVI
Waterlemon Cay. Not watermelon. I said it wrong at least five times before I got it right.
It's a short adventure more than a beach stop.
You park by the Annaberg Sugar Plantation, walk about 20 minutes along the Leinster Bay Trail, and pick your way past a lot of sea urchins to get in. We got there around 9 am and shared it with only one other couple.
On an island where the popular beaches can get really crowded, this felt suspiciously peaceful.
The payoff was two nurse sharks asleep on the bottom. It was our favorite snorkel on the island.
Entry tips and where to swim are in my Waterlemon Cay Guide.
2. Swim with Turtles at Francis Bay
A turtle at Francis Bay in St. John USVI
I went in expecting very little at Francis Bay and lost count after 10 turtles. The water is calm and the entry is soft sand, so this is the one I'd send a nervous first-time snorkeler to.
Next door, Maho Bay gets more of the turtle fame and more of the crowds. Its draw is Maho Crossroads across the road, a pop-up spot with a tiki bar, a food truck in an old VW bus, and water sports rentals.
If you want a drink with your beach day, go to Maho.
If you want just the turtles with fewer crowds and a wider beach, go to Francis.
3. Spend a Slow Afternoon at Hansen Bay
Hansen Bay beach
I used to call Hansen Bay the secret beach. The secret's out, but it's still where I'd go for an afternoon of swimming and sitting.
Thalia, who owns the land in front of the beach, keeps it clean and runs it on donations. When we visited, she had chairs, kayaks, and paddleboards to borrow, plus picnic tables and portable bathrooms.
Bring cash for the donation box. We loved unwinding in the shaded chairs between swims, and we saw turtles in the shallow bay.
It's on the East End, next to Haulover Bay North, one of our favorite snorkel spots. We did Haulover first thing, Hansen before lunch, then drove to Skinny Legs.
It's an easy East End day.
4. Take the Jeep to the South Shore Bays
Driving in a Jeep to Little Lameshur Bay in St. John USVI
Some of the best snorkeling spots on St. John make you work for it, and the drive is half the story.
The roads to Little Lameshur Bay and Grootpan Bay are rough dirt, and you need a 4WD. We were in a Jeep and there were still stretches where I considered turning around.
If it has rained recently, use common sense.
The reward is near-empty beaches. When we pulled into Grootpan there was one other car. It's rugged and a little wild, with a pebbly beach, so it's not a lounge-all-day stop.
Bring your own gear and a waterproof bag for the car keys. Where to swim at each is in the two guides linked above.
5. Hike Ram Head (and Skip the Spur Trail)
Hiking Ram Head in St. John
Ram Head was the only hike we did on St. John, so I can't rank it against Reef Bay or the others. I can tell you it was worth a morning, and that we made it harder than it needed to be.
The trail starts at the Salt Pond Bay parking lot.
It's about 2 miles round trip and takes around 90 minutes if you stay on the actual trail. You pass the salt pond, follow the rocky shoreline, then cross Blue Cobblestone Beach before the climb.
We went wrong about halfway down Blue Cobblestone, where there's a well-marked spur trail that looks like the route. It isn't.
We followed it up a steep slope until the path disappeared, then bushwhacked back through thick brush and giant spider webs.
That detour cost us almost 50 minutes and a very unhappy husband. Keep walking to the far end of the beach and you'll pick up the real trail.
The last stretch climbs past clusters of Turks head cacti to views with the ocean in every direction and a breeze you'll be grateful for.
There's almost no shade, so go early and bring more water than you think you need.
When you're back, cool off at Salt Pond Bay, not Blue Cobblestone.
Full directions are in my Ram Head hiking guide, and more of our favorite day hikes around the world are on my Hike & Bike page.
6. Spend a Beach Day at Trunk Bay
Swimming at Trunk Bay Beach in St. John USVI
Trunk Bay is the kind of beach that makes you stop mid-sentence.
The sand is soft enough to feel fake, and the water is that bright aquamarine that makes you question every other beach you've defended.
The World's 50 Best Beaches list ranked it number one in 2024, and that didn't surprise me.
It's also one of the few beaches on St. John set up for a full, easy day.
When we went there was a snack bar, a bar, chair rentals, showers, and restrooms. We grabbed a rum punch and a Lime N Da Coconut at the beach bar.
The National Park Service charges a $5 per person amenity fee for anyone 16 and older.
We arrived around 9:30 am and there were three parking spots left, so go early, and check the cruise ship schedule before you pick a day.
My 8 tips for Trunk Bay cover the rest.
Come for the beach, not the snorkel trail. It was crowded and choppy the day we swam it, and Cinnamon Bay next door was better for the fish.
7. Order the Grouper Reuben at Miss Lucy's
Grouper reuben at Miss Lucy's in St. John USVI
Miss Lucy's sits right on the water on the Coral Bay side. It's laid-back, and we stayed longer than we meant to.
We split the crunchy fish and the grouper Reuben. A grouper Reuben sounded odd to me, but it was our favorite dish there.
Perfectly cooked fish on toasted rye with slaw, Swiss, and a tangy remoulade that somehow worked.
This is also where I had my first Lime N Da Coconut, which is rum, fresh lime, and coconut blended into something dangerously easy to drink.
Check the hours before you drive over. Miss Lucy's keeps short hours these days, mostly weekday lunches plus a Thursday evening, and it's closed several days a week.
8. Get a Painkiller at Skinny Legs
Stopping for a burger and Painkiller at Skinny Legs in St. John USVI
Skinny Legs has been part of Coral Bay since 1991, when Moe and Dougie opened it.
The vibe is super casual: no pressure, good food, people hanging out. The burgers were some of the best we had on the island, simple and juicy.
Get the Painkiller. It's strong, smooth, and goes down a little too easily.
We came here for a late lunch after a morning on the East End, which is the order I'd recommend.
This is a St. John institution. Island life at its best!
9. Browse Mongoose Junction and Grab Lunch
Pastrami Tsunami Sandwich from North Shore Deli in St. John USVI
One place I enjoy in Cruz Bay is Mongoose Junction, a cluster of small shops selling art, jewelry, beach decor, and clothing, plus a few good places to eat.
Our favorite sandwich stop there is North Shore Deli.
It does slow-roasted meat sandwiches, fresh salads, and smoothies, and it's set up for grabbing lunch on your way to Trunk, Cinnamon, Maho, or Francis.
We can personally vouch for the Pastrami Tsunami and the Superfood Salad.
10. Try the Sea Moss Smoothie
Shaibu's Gourmet Grab & Go Entrance in St. John USVI
Shaibu's Gourmet Grab & Go is a vegetarian counter on the second floor of The Marketplace in Cruz Bay, near Starfish Market. It became one of our favorite low-key stops.
Chef Shaibu Abdulai is originally from Ghana and studied at the Culinary Institute of America before building his food business on St. John.
We ordered the cold noodle Thai peanut salad and a veggie panini, and both were packed with flavor.
The surprise was the sea moss smoothie. I was skeptical, since it sounds like something you talk yourself into liking. It was delicious.
I also grabbed a turmeric ginger juice. I'm not saying it fixed my whole body after a day of hiking and snorkeling, but it came close!
11. Make Cocktails with Local Rum
Lime n da coconut drink made with Botany Bay rum in Coral Bay, St. John USVI
We like to get a feel for a place through what we're drinking.
In Oaxaca it was mezcal. On Saba it was Saba Spice. In Barbados we found Foursquare and haven't stopped talking about it.
On St. John, the bottle we brought back to the villa was Botany Bay Estate Reserve, a blended rum from Old Estate Rums on St. Thomas, aged in French and American oak.
It became the base of our homemade Lime N Da Coconut phase. If you like rum even a little, it's an easy bottle to bring home.
12. Do Nothing for a Day on a Villa Balcony
Enjoying our pool and view at our villa rental in Coral Bay in St. John
By day eight we'd been in the water almost every day, so we stayed put. We swam in the villa pool, stared at Coral Bay from the balcony, and worked through that bottle of rum.
We stayed at Anchorage Aweigh, a villa high in the hills above the harbor with a wraparound balcony. The balcony is the reason this day made the list.
We chose Coral Bay for the views and the quick drive to the south shore and East End beaches, and I'd choose it again.
Cruz Bay is the better pick if you'd rather walk to dinner and skip the steep night drives.
My guide to where to stay on St. John breaks down every area.
What I'd Skip
- The Trunk Bay snorkel trail, if your days are limited. Go for the beach.
- The Ram Head spur trail. See #5. Fifty minutes we won't get back.
- A tight return ferry. On our last day we took the noon car barge back to St. Thomas for a 2:55 pm flight. We made it, but it was cutting it too close.
Who Should Think Twice About St. John
Haha! Only in St. John. Waiting for the donkeys to move so we can keep driving.
Almost everything on this list assumes a rental car, and the roads are steep, narrow, and driven on the left.
If you'd rather walk everywhere, stay in Cruz Bay and plan on taxis to the North Shore beaches.
And if you want a big resort, your choices are limited. Most visitors stay in vacation rentals.
What We Didn't Get To
These are on my list for next time.
- Lime Out. A floating taco bar anchored in Coral Bay harbor that you can only reach by boat, kayak, or paddleboard. Looks like so much fun! It takes a seasonal break in the fall, so check before you plan around it.
- The Reef Bay Trail. The well-known hike we didn't have time for. It's first on my list for a return trip.
Getting Around: Jeep, Car Barge, Driving on the Left
Our Jeep rental from Amalie Car Rental
St. John is better on your own schedule.
We rented a Jeep from Amalie Car Rental on St. Thomas. They met us curbside at the airport, and we drove 30 minutes to Red Hook and took the car barge to Cruz Bay.
You'll drive on the left. It takes a minute, but after I drove all over Madeira, it felt manageable.
The East End and the roads up to the Coral Bay villas are steep and winding, and that's where the Jeep earned its keep.
Download an offline map before you go, because cell service is patchy.
What I'd Tell a Friend
St. John reminded me a little of Kauai: lush, a bit rugged, and full of things to do if you plan it.
Get in the water in the morning, when it was usually calmer and the beaches emptier.
Base yourself in Coral Bay if the beaches and reefs are the point of the trip, and in Cruz Bay if you want restaurants within walking distance.
And leave one day with nothing planned, because by day eight we needed it.
If you're still choosing between islands, here's how St. John compares with St. Croix.
If you're ready to plan, start with my 9-day St. John itinerary.
It's how we'd do it again.
We are very new on traveling and we are wanting to go to one of the islands, St. John Island or St. Croix Island. We are looking for staying in a resort that are right on the beach, beach front rooms and we are looking to relax and want a quieter island. This is a vacation to unwind leave our stresses behind.
Can you help us and give us some ideas on where to go and stay? We need any and all help you can give us.
Thank you so very much
Thanks for reaching out. Great choices … both St. John and St. Croix are beautiful.
To help you decide between the two islands, I have written a post comparing the two that hopefully helps you to decide: St John vs St Croix.
To answer your question on where to stay in St. John and St. Croix, don’t miss my two articles that go over the different neighborhoods in both St. John and St. Croix and the best properties in each:
Where to Stay in St Croix
Where to Stay in St John
See #12. The “drop” down to Maho from the Majestic Mile is about 5 minutes. Worth the view, breeze, peace up on the hill.
Thank you for sharing! St. John really is my happy place. I could sit outside with that Coral Bay view for hours.
Where was your bio picture taken?
That was taken out on the balcony at Selva Cocktail Bar in Oaxaca. Cool place with a lot of interesting drinks. If you snag one of the balcony tables, you get a great view over the city!