I wouldn't want to see St. John without a car. Two of my favorite snorkel sites sit at the end of rough dirt roads, and the beach parking lots we used were filling up by late morning.
St. John has rental companies of its own, but we picked up our Jeep at the St. Thomas airport and drove it onto the car barge. So many fellow travelers had recommended Amalie Car Rental that the decision was easy.
Here's how that worked over our nine days, what I'd change about the Jeep we drove, and when renting on St. John makes more sense.
This post may contain affiliate links. If you purchase through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only recommend places and products I’ve tried myself.
In This Post
The Short Answer
- Staying on St. John, flying into St. Thomas: rent on St. Thomas from a company that lets the car go on the barge, then drive it across. That's what we did, with Amalie.
- Arriving without a car: take the passenger ferry and rent a car in Cruz Bay, St. John.
- Heading to Little Lameshur or Grootpan: get a Jeep or another four-wheel drive. Both roads turn to rough dirt.
- Going at the holidays: book the car first. Amalie told me they generally book up about 2 months ahead in the busy winter season, and 6 weeks out they were already sold out for one of our upcoming trips.
St. Thomas or St. John?
Renting on St. Thomas means the car is waiting when you land and you hand it back at the airport on your last day. The trade-off is the barge, both ways.
On our flight day, the wait at the St. John barge dock ran far longer than we'd planned, and we reached the airport under two hours before our flight.
The schedules, fares and how loading works are in my guide to getting to St. John by car barge, ferry or water taxi.
Renting on St. John means a taxi from the St. Thomas airport to the ferry dock with your bags, the passenger ferry, and a pickup in Cruz Bay.
You skip the barge, but you'll need taxis on St. Thomas at both ends of the trip.
| Rent on St. Thomas | Rent on St. John | |
|---|---|---|
| Pickup | At or near the STT airport | Cruz Bay, after the ferry |
| Getting across | Car barge from Red Hook, priced per vehicle | Taxi plus passenger ferry, priced per person and bag |
| Flight day | Barge back, then drive to the airport | Return the car, ferry back, taxi to the airport |
| Check first | That the company allows the barge | Pickup hours and how you reach the lot |
Our Amalie Review
Booking
Amalie is locally owned, and Amy James, the owner, carries it on from the Constantin family.
We started with the reservation form on Amalie's website, but the form is only a request.
We still had to call to confirm with Amy the Jeep was available, and we gave our credit card over the phone to finish the booking.
We reserved a two-door 4x4 automatic Jeep Wrangler with AC and paid $785 for the week. That’s still Amalie's weekly rate for the two-door, and the four-door is $825.
There were no surprise fees on the bill, and adding my husband as a second driver cost nothing.
Pickup
Our bright red Amalie Jeep in St. John USVI
An Amalie rep met us at the curb outside baggage claim, drove us a few minutes to the Jeep, and we were pulling away within minutes.
The Jeep had a big "Keep Left" sticker as a reminder. You drive on the left in the USVI.
They'd upgraded us to a four-door. It had more room, but I'd have kept the two-door we booked.
It's smaller and easier to drive, and you reverse onto the barge into a tight spot beside other cars.
Having the Jeep from the airport meant we could stop at Starfish Market in Cruz Bay for groceries on the way to our villa in Coral Bay.
It was the best of the grocery stores we tried, and I list the others in my guide to where to stay on St. John.
Return
On our last day, Amalie texted to ask what time to meet us, and a rep was waiting at the curb when we pulled up at the airport.
The return is where our own timing went wrong, not Amalie's. We left our villa at 9:30 am for a 2:55 pm flight and didn't get on a barge until noon.
My St. John itinerary has the full flight day.
If Amalie is booked
Amalie was sold out when I tried to book them again for one of our upcoming trips, so I looked at who else on St. Thomas gets strong reviews.
On Google, Enterprise had the top rating of the big name chains I checked, at 4.5.
When we travel, we lean toward locally owned companies over the big names.
Paradise Car Rental and Go Car Rental are two local companies that also rate well there.
We booked Go Car Rental. It has fewer reviews than the others, but the ones it has are very good, so I'm crossing my fingers. I'll add how it went after our trip.
Jeep or Car?
Driving in our Jeep to Little Lameshur Bay in St. John USVI
Get the Jeep if Little Lameshur or Grootpan is on your list.
They're the third- and fifth-ranked sites in my St. John snorkeling guide, and both take some driving.
- Little Lameshur Bay: The route eventually runs out of pavement and turns into a bumpy, potholed dirt road. I wouldn't drive it after heavy rain.
- Grootpan Bay: several turns on a poorly kept road. Download the map before you go.
The roads up to the Coral Bay villas are steep too, with tight switchbacks I call kiss-your-butt curves. Our Jeep handled them well.
Hubby driving our Jeep on the steep hills in Coral Bay, St. John
A smaller Jeep also helps squeezing in at the beach lots. At Salt Pond Bay the lot was nearly empty at 9:30 am and full by noon.
Before You Book
Car barge coming into St. John from St. Thomas
- Ask if the car can go on the barge. I've read that some St. Thomas companies don't allow their cars on St. John. I'm not sure which ones, so always ask before you book.
- Ask what happens if it breaks down on St. John. With Amalie, you call them, and they work with a local mechanic on St. John to help you.
- Ask for a backup camera. Reversing onto the barge is much easier with one.
- Download an offline map. Cell service on St. John was spotty for us.
- Check holiday hours. Some rental companies close on holidays. St. John Car Rental's website says it's closed on July 4, Thanksgiving, Christmas and New Year's Day, and Sunshine's Jeep Rental told me they're closed on New Year's Day. If your trip starts or ends on a holiday, check pickup and return days before you lock in your villa dates.
Renting on St. John
Our villa sent us a long list of St. John rental companies before our trip. These were the highest rated ones on Google: St. John Car Rental, Aqua Blu Car Rental, Sunshine's Jeep Rental, Slim Man's, and Varlack Ventures.
The best reason to rent on St. John is parking. If you've driven into Cruz Bay, you know how hard it is to find a spot.
Recent traveler reviews say St. John Car Rental and Sunshine's Jeep Rental let renters park in their lots while in Cruz Bay during the evening.
That matters if you're staying outside town and want to come in for dinner, so check with the company first if it's important to you.
What I'd Tell a Friend
If you're staying on St. John, rent with Amalie on St. Thomas and drive the car across.
We left the airport in our own Jeep without waiting for a taxi, and we had it from the first afternoon.
Confirm the barge is allowed before you pay, whoever you rent from.
Get a Jeep if you want Little Lameshur and Grootpan.
Snorkeling is a big reason we travel, and I rate every site we swim out of five masks. Both of these got four, and both sit at the end of rough dirt roads that call for four-wheel drive.
Give the return day more time than we did. For what we did with the Jeep the rest of the week, see my favorite things to do in St. John.
0 Comments