My husband and I spent nine days on St. John and eight on St. Croix, both in December.
It didn't take long to realize how different these two islands are. St. John is small, steep and mostly national park, with a beach or a snorkel site around almost every bend.
St. Croix is about four times bigger, with more local food, hiking and far more places to stay right on the water.
Below is how they compare on the things that decided it for us: beaches, snorkeling, food, hiking, pace, cost, where you'll stay and how you get there.
Every pick is something we did ourselves.
This post may contain affiliate links. If you purchase through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only recommend places and products I’ve tried myself.
In This Post
The Short Answer
- If snorkeling from the beach is the main reason you're going, pick St. John. Five of the 11 sites we swam there got four masks from me. On St. Croix, one of five did.
- If you love local food and want to hike, pick St. Croix. The best BBQ chicken of our lives came off a roadside grill there, and we did three hikes in eight days.
- If you're not a strong swimmer, pick St. John. Francis Bay and Maho Bay are calm, with soft sandy entries.
- If you want to wake up on the water, pick St. Croix. Oceanfront rentals were much easier to find there.
- If you'd rather fly straight to the island, pick St. Croix. St. John has no airport, so you fly into St. Thomas and cross by car barge or ferry.
Side by Side Comparison
| St. John | St. Croix | |
|---|---|---|
| Beaches | Numerous top beaches, like Trunk Bay | Sandy Point and Rainbow Beach |
| Snorkeling | 11 shore sites, five at four masks | 5 sites, one at four masks (Frederiksted Pier) |
| Food | Burgers, deli sandwiches, Coral Bay beach bars | La Reine BBQ chicken, Ziggy's at the gas station |
| Hiking | Ram Head and Reef Bay Trail, plus short walks to snorkel sites | Annaly Bay, Mount Eagle, Isaac and Jack Bay |
| Getting there | Fly into St. Thomas, then car barge or ferry | Fly straight in |
| Car | Jeep, with 4WD for the south shore bays | Compact SUV |
| Oceanfront stays | Hard to find | Easier to find |
| We'd pick it for | Beaches and snorkeling | Food, hiking and cost |
1. Beaches
Walking along the powdery sand at Trunk Bay Beach in St. John USVI
St John
St. John has some incredible beaches, and Trunk Bay is the famous one.
The World's 50 Best Beaches named it the number one beach in the world in 2024, then moved it into its "Best of the Best" hall of fame, so it no longer appears in the yearly ranking.
The sand is soft and white and the water is clear turquoise. It was also the busiest beach we went to, so get there early.
Cinnamon Bay, right next door, felt like a less crowded version with better snorkeling. We even saw a lemon shark. My Trunk Bay guide has the parking and fee details.
On the North Shore, Trunk, Cinnamon, Maho and Francis sit a few minutes' drive apart. Most of the 11 sites in my St. John snorkeling guide start from a beach.
Relaxing at Rainbow Beach in St. Croix
St. Croix
St. Croix's best beach, for me, is Sandy Point.
It's one of the most beautiful beaches we've seen in the Caribbean, with about two miles of soft white sand, and Beach.com's 2026 Global Beach Index ranked it seventh in the world (Trunk Bay was #1).
The catch is access. It's a wildlife refuge for nesting leatherback sea turtles, so it's open only Saturdays and Sundays from 10 am to 4 pm, and it closes completely from April through August. There's no shade and no reef.
St. Croix's other beaches are lovely too. Isaac Bay takes a 20-minute hike and we had it almost to ourselves.
Dorsch Beach on the west side has calm water and an easy sandy entry. Rainbow Beach faces west, so it's the one for sunset.
Cane Bay was our home beach. Beautiful in their own right, they just don't quite match the wow factor of St. John's beaches.
Winner: St. John
2. Snorkeling
Snorkeling with a sea turtle at Maho Bay in St. John USVI
St. John
We're big snorkeling fans, and we've been lucky enough to snorkel in places like the Maldives and Moorea.
On St. John, we swam 11 sites in nine days without a single boat tour. You park, walk a few minutes and get in.
I rate every site we snorkel from one to five masks, and the low scores get published too. Blue Cobblestone, near Ram Head, got one. These five got four:
- Waterlemon Cay: two nurse sharks asleep on the bottom
- Haulover Bay North: huge purple sea fans, schools of fish, and a stingray
- Francis Bay: 10+ turtles, and the calm, sandy entry I'd send a beginner to
- Little Lameshur Bay and Grootpan Bay: both at the end of rough dirt roads, so you need a 4WD
Snorkeling with a school of jacks at Buck Island
St. Croix
On St. Croix, Frederiksted Pier is the one I'd fly back for.
The pylons are covered in red, orange and yellow coral, and we haven't snorkeled anything like it anywhere else. Swimming around the pier isn't allowed when a cruise ship is docked, so check the schedule first.
The rest got three masks or less. Buck Island is boat only, with a massive school of jacks but mostly dead coral. Cane Bay had juvenile turtles, and Dorsch Beach had starfish in several colors.
One thing both islands share: we went in December, and the Christmas winds made some snorkel days rough on both.
All five St. Croix sites are in my St. Croix snorkeling guide.
Winner: St. John
3. Food
Watching all the chickens roasting on the spit at La Reine Chicken Shack
St. Croix
St. Croix is a standout when it comes to food. I'd argue it has some of the best eats in the U.S. Virgin Islands.
La Reine Chicken Shack on Centerline Road was our favorite.
We were obsessed with the spit-roasted BBQ chicken, with its crispy skin and juicy meat, and the baked macaroni. Easily the best we had on the island.
Ziggy's Island Market on the East End serves local food out of a gas station. They were making a fresh batch of curry when we got there that needed a few more hours, so we had the Cubano.
It was good, but I wish I'd tried the curry. And the coconut roll at Thomas Bakery was flaky, sweet and packed with coconut.
At Rhythms at Rainbow Beach, which calls itself the original home of the Lime in Da Coconut, we had a few of those with mahi tacos.
My St. Croix things to do guide has all of these.
St. Croix also hosts Taste of St. Croix, a yearly food festival with the island's chefs and restaurants. The dates have moved around, so check them if you want to plan around it.
Eating at grouper reuben at Miss Lucy's in St. John USVI
St. John
St. John also has some great places to eat. One of our favorite meals there was the grouper reuben at Miss Lucy's on the water in Coral Bay.
Weird combo, yes, but it works and it is incredible! We also loved the burgers and Painkillers at Skinny Legs, and the Pastrami Tsunami at North Shore Deli.
On both trips we cooked most meals at the villa, and a lot of the St. Croix places on our list were closed or on short hours when we were there. Even so, St. Croix gave us the better meals.
Winner: St. Croix
4. Hiking
Swimming in the clear waters of the Annaly Bay Tide Pools in St. Croix
St. Croix
St. Croix kept us on the trails.
The Annaly Bay Tide Pools take about an hour of hiking each way through the rainforest, and you need low tide to scramble over to the pools.
We hiked Mount Eagle, the island's high point, on Christmas morning, in about 40 minutes up. Readers have since told me about a landslide and an overgrown parking area, so ask locals before you go.
Isaac and Jack Bay is 20 minutes to each beach with almost no shade, so start early.
Hubby hiking the summit at Ram Head in St. John
St. John
On St. John, our one real hike was Ram Head: about 2 miles round trip, roughly 90 minutes, with big views at the end.
Most of our other walking was a few minutes to a snorkel site. The Reef Bay Trail is the one I wish we'd had time for.
Winner: St. Croix
5. Vibe
Driving past the resident donkeys on St. John
St. John
St. John feels busier, especially around Cruz Bay and the North Shore beaches.
Parking at the popular bays fills up by late morning. That's one of the reasons we loved staying in Coral Bay.
It felt more laid-back, with a fun, relaxed "hippie vibe" and the occasional goat or donkey blocking the road. Get up early and you can still find quiet on St. John.
At 9 am, we shared Waterlemon Cay with one other couple.
St. Croix
St. Croix is the largest of the U.S. Virgin Islands, so everything feels more spread out and less congested.
It's about an hour's drive from one end to the other. As we drove around and chatted with locals, we really got a sense of the island's culture and easygoing pace.
Winner: Tie
6. Cost
Walking through the produce aisle at Starfish Market in St. John
Overall, we found vacation rentals on St. Croix more affordable than on St. John. Grocery prices were noticeably lower too.
St. John
On St. John, we checked out four grocery stores: Starfish, Dolphin Market, Calabash and Love City.
Starfish was the largest of the bunch, though still relatively small, and it had the best prices of the four for what we bought. Groceries on St. John still run pretty pricey.
Getting to St. John adds a cost St. Croix doesn't have: the car barge from St. Thomas, which charges per vehicle each way.
Kirkland items I found at Plaza West in St. Croix
St. Croix
On St. Croix, we did all our grocery shopping at The Market (it was called Plaza West when we went).
Prices were reasonable, the local produce was good, and they had plenty of bulk Costco items. They even carried my favorite Kirkland Organic Strawberry Spread!
Winner: St. Croix
7. Where You'll Stay
Our St John villa in Coral Bay, St. John
St. John
St. John is steep, with winding roads and rolling hills. A lot of the vacation rentals sit high up, with big views.
More than half the island is national park land, according to the National Park Service, and finding a rental right on the sand was tricky.
Our view from our villa rental in St. John
My husband and I loved waking up each morning to the view over Coral Bay from our villa's balcony and pool.
My guide to where to stay on St. John breaks down the neighborhoods.
Our villa at Cane Bay, St. Croix
St. Croix
St. Croix is flatter overall, with its hills spread over a much bigger island, so you get fewer of those dramatic hilltop views.
What you get instead is the ocean.
Our rental at Cane Bay sat right on the cliffs, a five-minute walk from the beach, and we fell asleep to the waves every night.
My waterfront view at our villa in Cane Bay, St. Croix
Beachfront stays are much easier to find on St. Croix, especially around Frederiksted and Christiansted.
My guide to where to stay on St. Croix covers both towns and Cane Bay.
Winner: Tie
8. Getting There
A map of the Car Barge Route from St. Thomas to St. John
St. John
St. John has no airport.
We flew into St. Thomas, picked up a Jeep from Amalie Car Rental at the curb and took the car barge across from Red Hook.
My guide to getting to St. John covers the barge, the ferries and how much time to leave for your flight home (we cut ours a little too close).
You'll want a Jeep: the roads are steep, you drive on the left, and Little Lameshur and Grootpan need 4WD.
St. Croix
St. Croix is simpler. We flew straight in, picked up a compact SUV from Centerline Car Rentals at the airport and were at our rental in about 25 minutes.
Both trips took us about six to seven hours from the East Coast with one layover: Atlanta on the way to St. Thomas, Miami for St. Croix.
What I'd Tell a Friend
If snorkeling is the reason you're going, book St. John, rent a Jeep and plan your days around Waterlemon Cay, Haulover Bay North and Francis Bay.
Go early and you'll beat the crowds and the parking problem.
If you care more about food, hiking and waking up on the water, book St. Croix.
Eat at La Reine at least once, do Annaly Bay at low tide, and snorkel Frederiksted Pier on a day with no cruise ship in.
If you're coming in December like we did, plan on the Christmas winds either way.
My 9-day St. John itinerary and 8-day St. Croix itinerary show how we fit it all in. We loved both islands, each for its own reasons.
Excellent article for those considering the two islands … thank you for you thoughts you can pretty much disregard my trip advisor question… this was my exact question
So glad to hear this article helped. Happy to answer any other questions that might come up comparing the 2 islands.
Would like to do some travel with my partner. Difficulty choosing between St John or St Croix. Not a good swimmer
Older retiree
If you’re an older retiree and not a strong swimmer, I’d lean toward St. John. It has calm beaches like Maho and Francis Bay that are great for easy swimming and relaxing. And if you’d rather not do a lot of driving, Cruz Bay has plenty of shops, restaurants, and bars close by so you can keep things simple and just enjoy your time with your partner.
Great info Nichole, many thanks for this! Your lists answered so many of the questions we’ve had. STJ is our happy place but certainly going to give STX a look for sure.
So glad to hear this post helped! I was in your same boat not too long ago trying to figure out if STX was worth it. STJ will always be my first love, but STX was a nice change up.
Nichole, great comparison. We are scheduled for st Croix in a few weeks and wish I would have seen this before. Should we try to do a day trip over to St John in your opinion.
Great question. I would not do St. John as a day trip. You would be wasting so much time going between the islands. To get to St. John, you would have to go back to St. Thomas first and then take a ferry over to St. John.
At one point, there was limited direct ferry service between St. Croix and St. John, but I’m not sure if they are operating anymore.
I would advise having an amazing time in St. Croix and enjoying St. John on another vacation.
This is a great article! Thank you for putting it together, you absolutely nailed everything! Every year we consider STJ for the better beaches but then pick STX for the being able to walk out my front door onto the beach. Maybe I just need to a week on each
Thank you for sharing that kind feedback!
I agree … a week on each island is ideal! Both are great for different reasons. I need more vacation days. 😊
Thank you for this! I actually stumbled upon your blog last year while planning a trip to French Polynesia, now here I am again looking at a USVI trip next year. Thanks for the great content. I’m not a super strong swimmer/snorkeler – by any chance did you happen to find a USVI equivalent of Alex Lagoon Tours?? 🙂
Thank you so much for reaching out! 😊 I love hearing that you’ve found the blog helpful for multiple trips.
One of the best things about the USVI, especially St. John, is that you can access so many amazing snorkeling spots right from the beach. No boat required. For our visits to St. John and St. Croix, we didn’t do any snorkeling tours.
There are a few snorkeling cruises if you’d like to get out on the water (like the one run by Cruz Bay Watersports), but nothing quite like the small, intimate style that Alex Lagoon Tours offers in Moorea.
If you’re not a super strong swimmer, Francis Bay and Maho Bay are both wonderful beginner-friendly spots. Calm waters, easy access, and plenty of turtles!