The best snorkel we did on St. Croix was under a cruise ship pier.
Every pylon at Frederiksted Pier is covered in red, orange and yellow coral and sponges, and it was the only site on the island that earned four masks from us.
Buck Island, the one everyone books, came in at three.
Most of the coral on its underwater trail is dead. I still think it's worth going, and we swam right through a massive school of jacks.
My husband and I plan entire trips around snorkeling. We've snorkeled 87 sites, beside eagle rays in Bonaire, turtles in St. John, penguins in the Galapagos and blacktip reef sharks in Moorea, and over the house reefs of the Maldives.
On St. Croix, we spent eight days, swam five sites, and did every one but Buck Island from shore.
St. John has better snorkeling, and I'd rather say that up front.
We went over Christmas, and the Christmas winds made three of our five swims rough. Frederiksted Pier alone is worth packing your fins for.
All five sites are ranked here best to worst, with where to get in, what we saw, and a link to the full guide for each.
This post may contain affiliate links. If you purchase through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only recommend places and products I’ve tried myself.
In This Post
St. Croix Snorkeling: The Short Answer
- If you only snorkel once: Frederiksted Pier, on a day with no cruise ship docked.
- For beginners: Dorsch Beach, on the calmer west side, with a sandy entry. We found starfish in several colors.
- For turtles: keep expectations low. We saw a few juvenile turtles at Cane Bay. If turtles are the goal, go to St. John, where I lost count after 10 at Francis Bay.
- For a boat day: Buck Island. It's the only site here you need a boat for, and only approved operators can take you.
- For a hike and a swim: Isaac Bay on the East End. The hike was the better half.
- On a cruise? Swimming and snorkeling around Frederiksted Pier aren't allowed while your ship is docked. Dorsch Beach is a few minutes' drive south of the pier.
- Coming in December? Plan your snorkeling for the west side. The Christmas winds made Buck Island, Cane Bay and Isaac Bay rough for us.
- St. Croix or St. John? If snorkeling is the main reason you're going, St. John. St. Croix wins on food.
St. Croix Snorkeling Rating System
Every site we swim gets a score out of five masks, on the same scale we use in Bonaire or the Maldives.
The score is based on what we saw on our visit and how it stacks up against the other sites we've snorkeled.
On St. Croix, a three meant decent snorkeling and worth the effort. Only the pier earned a four.
My Snorkel Rating Key
🤿 🤿 🤿 🤿 🤿 = World-class snorkeling and worth traveling just for the snorkeling alone!
🤿 🤿 🤿 🤿 = Incredible snorkeling and should be on your list of top things to do!
🤿 🤿 🤿 = Decent snorkeling and worth the effort!
🤿 🤿 = Worth consideration if you are running out of things to do!
🤿 = Not worth it!
Map of St. Croix Snorkeling Sites
Snorkeling Map of St. Croix USVI
| Site | Area | Access | Level | Rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Frederiksted Pier | West End, Frederiksted | Free, shore | Easy to moderate | 🤿🤿🤿🤿 |
| 2. Buck Island | Off the northeast coast | Boat tour only | Moderate to confident | 🤿🤿🤿 |
| 3. Cane Bay | North shore | Free, shore | Moderate | 🤿🤿🤿 |
| 4. Dorsch Beach | West End, south of Frederiksted | Free, shore | Beginner | 🤿🤿🤿 |
| 5. Isaac Bay | East End | Free, 20 min hike | Moderate to confident | 🤿🤿 |
We stayed at this amazing cliffside rental at Cane Bay, in the middle of the north shore.
Frederiksted and Christiansted were each about 25 minutes away.
Here's our 8-day St. Croix itinerary showing how we fit all five in.
Each site below links to its own guide, with parking, entry photos, a map of where we swam, and the fish we photographed.
Bring your own gear. Two of these entries meant slippery rocks or urchins, and rental fins that don't fit make that harder.
Here's the snorkel gear I pack on every trip.
1. Frederiksted Pier
Snorkeling with sergeant majors under Frederiksted Pier in St. Croix
Rating: 🤿 🤿 🤿 🤿
Frederiksted Pier was our favorite snorkel on St. Croix, and we haven't snorkeled anything like it.
The pier is in the middle of Frederiksted on the west end. We parked on the street near Polly's at the Pier and walked over. Car break-ins happen, so don't leave anything valuable in the car.
The usual way in is a small sandy beach to the left of the pier, down a short staircase from the sidewalk.
That entry was closed when we went, so we walked around to the right side and climbed in off the rocks. They were slippery, and I was glad I had dive booties on with my open-heel fins.
Once you're in, it's easy. Swim along the pier and weave between the pylons. It's darker under there, so go on a sunny day. The light comes in at an angle and lights up the coral.
Most of the pylons are covered in red, orange and yellow coral and sponges, with brittle stars in the cracks.
We saw schools of blue tang and sergeant majors, a bait ball, a barracuda and a decorator crab. Along the rocks to the left of the pier as you face the water, we found a big group of squid.
Check the cruise schedule before you drive over. Swimming, snorkeling and diving around the pier aren't allowed when a ship is docked.
If Bonaire is on your list, Salt Pier is the other pier I'd send you to.
2. Buck Island
Snorkeling through a school of jacks at Buck Island
Rating: 🤿 🤿 🤿
Buck Island is at the top of most St. Croix lists, and it's the one site on ours you can't reach from shore.
The island and its reef are a national monument, and you can only snorkel it on a boat the National Park Service has approved.
We sailed out on a six-passenger trimaran with Llewellyn's Charter. Llewellyn has since retired, so my Buck Island guide compares the boats running now, by group size, sail or motor, and where they leave from.
Every tour starts at the marked underwater trail. The Christmas winds were picking up the day we went, and the water was choppy.
Be prepared that most of the coral is dead, though there are still some beautiful sections of elkhorn and brain coral.
The coolest thing we saw was a massive school of jacks, which we swam right through. We also saw parrotfish, blue tang and a barracuda.
Afterward, boats stop at Turtle Beach, a stretch of soft white sand for swimming and drying off. There's no snorkeling off this beach.
Book Buck Island for a calm day.
3. Cane Bay
Snorkeling with a small turtle at Cane Bay
Rating: 🤿 🤿 🤿
Cane Bay was our home base. Our cliffside rental was about a five-minute walk from the beach.
It's a shore entry right off Cane Bay Road. Parking gets tight when it's busy, so go early.
Find the concrete boat ramp in the middle of the beach and swim straight out through the gap in the reef. If you get in anywhere else, you risk stepping on coral and sea urchins.
We went right. The water gets rougher to the left.
We swam right before the Christmas winds kicked in, and visibility wasn't great.
The reef is patchy, but we saw coral, sea fans, schools of blue tang and a few juvenile turtles.
I've heard it looks like an aquarium on a calm day, and I'd like to go back and see it that way.
Divers come for The Wall, a steep drop-off out past the reef. It was too rough for us to swim out that far.
Sweet Bottom Dive Center, across the road, rents snorkel gear. The Landing Beach Bar is across the street for a drink and casual food after your swim.
Cane Bay is about 25 minutes from BOTH Christiansted and Frederiksted, which is a big reason I'd stay here again.
My guide to where to stay in St. Croix covers our rental and the other neighborhoods.
4. Dorsch Beach
Starfish at Dorsch Beach
Rating: 🤿 🤿 🤿
Dorsch Beach is where I'd send a beginner.
It's on the west side, just south of Frederiksted, where the water is usually calm, and the entry is soft sand.
Put Sand Castle on the Beach in your GPS, then drive a few minutes north toward Frederiksted. There's plenty of parking right on the beach.
Snorkel straight out, then head right toward the old abandoned stone shack.
Straight out from the beach, we found starfish in several colors. On the way to the shack, we passed plenty of barrel sponges.
In front of the shack, some old machinery dumped years ago is now covered in coral, with sergeant majors and French grunts swimming around it.
Other snorkelers report turtles and octopus here. We didn't see either. The starfish were what made it.
Beach Side Cafe at Sand Castle on the Beach, an adults-only hotel, is open to non-guests for lunch or a drink afterward.
5. Isaac Bay
Snorkeling past a few patches of elkhorn coral at Isaac Bay
Rating: 🤿 🤿
Isaac Bay is a hike first and a snorkel second. We had to work off all those rum punches somehow.
It's on the far East End. Park in the small strip of spaces on the right just before Point Udall, and get there early, because there are only a few.
The area is isolated and break-ins happen, so leave nothing in the car.
The hike took us about 20 minutes, past East End Bay and through low shrubs and cactus to a wooden staircase down to the beach.
There's almost no shade. We started at 11 am, and I don't recommend it.
Go early, and bring a wide-brimmed hat, reef-safe sunscreen and more water than you think you'll need.
At the bottom of the stairs, we turned left and left our things in a small shaded cove. The entry is sandy.
The wind had picked up, and the current pushed us from left to right, so I wore my snorkel vest.
The reef is patchy. We saw soft and hard coral, including elkhorn, sea fans, a few scattered fish, a sergeant major and a lobster.
The snorkeling was underwhelming. The hike and the nearly empty beach are why I'd still go.
This isn't a spot for beginners. If the current looks rough, stay out of the water and swim at Dorsch Beach instead.
Jack Bay is another 20 minutes down the trail. We hiked over to see it but were too wiped out to get back in the water.
St. Croix Snorkeling Tips
Snorkeling under the Frederiksted Pier
#1- Watch the Wind
We went over Christmas, as the Christmas winds were picking up.
They made Buck Island, Cane Bay and Isaac Bay choppy, and visibility at Cane Bay suffered.
If snorkeling is the main reason you're coming, keep that in mind when you pick your dates.
The west side, home to the pier and Dorsch Beach, is usually calmer.
#2- Check the Cruise Schedule
Frederiksted Pier is off limits to swimmers while a cruise ship is docked.
The Virgin Islands Port Authority publishes the ship schedule before each season, so check it before you plan your pier day.
#3- Wear Dive Booties
The rocks at the pier were slippery, and Cane Bay has coral and urchins on either side of the boat ramp. I wore dive booties with open-heel fins at both.
#4- Bring Your Own Gear
Sweet Bottom Dive Center at Cane Bay rents gear, but a mask and fins that fit make a big difference on rocky entries.
Here's my full snorkel packing list.
#5- Pack Mineral Sunscreen
The U.S. Virgin Islands banned sunscreens containing oxybenzone, octinoxate and octocrylene, and the ban took effect in 2020.
Mineral sunscreens with zinc oxide or titanium dioxide are allowed.
Here are my favorite reef-safe sunscreens. I also wear a long sleeve rash guard so I need less of it.
#6- Rent a Car
St. Croix is a big island. The pier is on the west end, and Isaac Bay is on the far east. We rented from Centerline Car Rentals and had a great experience.
At every parking spot, leave nothing valuable in the car.
#7- Know the Reefs Have Changed
Stony coral tissue loss disease was confirmed on St. Croix's reefs in 2020. Some sites may have less live coral today.
What I'd Tell a Friend
If you only get in the water once, make it Frederiksted Pier, on a sunny morning with no ship in port.
If you want a boat day, book Buck Island and pick a calm one. Go for the jacks and Turtle Beach, and be ready for a lot of dead coral on the trail.
Stay at Cane Bay, so the pier and Christiansted are each about 25 minutes away. Start a beginner at Dorsch Beach. Treat Isaac Bay as a hike with a swim at the end, and finish at Ziggy's.
If snorkeling is the whole point of your trip, go to St. John.
If you want great local food, good hikes and a couple of snorkels worth planning around, St. Croix makes a very good week.
For everything else we did on the island, here are the 13 things I'd do in St. Croix, and here's how St. John and St. Croix compare.
Thank you so much for your perspective! I am blessed to live on St. Croix and just started snorkeling recently. I am hooked! I have only snorkeled around Sandcastles beach area, but I am really looking forward to checking out the pier as soon as I find a snorkel buddy. I will definitely check out all your suggestions. Thank you for sharing!
Thank you for sharing that kind feedback. Wow, lucky you. St. Croix is such a beautiful island. Snorkeling around Frederiksted Pier is so much fun! Hope you get to experience it soon. 😊