You can't swim to Buck Island. The island and its reef are a national monument about 1.5 miles off St. Croix's northeast coast, and the only way in is on a boat the National Park Service has approved, or your own boat with a park permit.
My husband and I went with Llewellyn's Charter, a 6-passenger sailing trimaran, and the small boat made our day. Llewellyn has since retired and the charter no longer runs.
So this guide covers what our day was like, how the snorkeling rates, and what every current operator offers, including the boats I'd look at first if you want a small group like ours.
This post may contain affiliate links. If you purchase through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only recommend places and products I’ve tried myself.
In This Post
Which Boat to Book
- If we went again: I'd book Wave Dancer's shared trip. It's a sailing catamaran with up to 16 guests, the smallest shared trip to Buck Island, at $125 per adult for six hours.
- If you're splitting a private boat with family or friends: the most affordable are Dragonfly (sail, up to eight, $1,200 per boat, or $150 each for eight) and Smooth Recovery (motor, up to 12, from $900 for three hours).
- Bigger shared groups: Teroro II, Snorkelers in Paradise and Celebration take 24 to 28. Big Beard's boats take 35 to 40.
- Lunch included: Big Beard's full day, $140 per adult.
Our Buck Island Trip
Llewellyn's Charter sailboat at Turtle Beach at Buck Island
We booked Llewellyn's because it was a small snorkeling group.
The boat was a 37-foot trimaran with no motor that took six passengers at most, so there were no gas fumes, just the wind in the sails.
With only six of us following the guide on the trail, we each had room to stop and look.
Llewellyn had been sailing to Buck Island since 1960, though he wasn't on board the day we went. The boat left from the St. Croix Yacht Club, and we reached it in a small rowboat.
We arrived at 9 am and were back around 1 pm.
The park's operator list may still show Llewellyn's name, so don't be surprised if you find it there and can't get through.
Buck Island Snorkeling
We've snorkeled all over the world, so we rate every site on the same five-mask scale.
It lets you compare Buck Island with a reef in Bonaire or a pier in St. Croix and decide where to spend your time.
My Snorkel Rating Key
🤿 🤿 🤿 🤿 🤿 = World-class snorkeling and worth traveling just for the snorkeling alone!
🤿 🤿 🤿 🤿 = Incredible snorkeling and should be on your list of top things to do!
🤿 🤿 🤿 = Decent snorkeling and worth the effort!
🤿 🤿 = Worth consideration if you are running out of things to do!
🤿 = Not worth it!
Buck Island has decent snorkeling and worth the effort, but it isn't the best reef we swam on St. Croix.
That was Frederiksted Pier, where every pylon is covered in coral and sponges.
The rest of the island's sites are ranked in my St. Croix snorkeling guide.
Rating: 🤿 🤿 🤿
Stop 1: The Underwater Trail
Snorkeling Map of Buck Island in St. Croix USVI
Every tour starts with the marked underwater trail on the east end of the island.
We put on our gear and the life vest our boat required, got in, and followed a guide along the trail.
I was glad for the vest that day, and I wear my own snorkel vest on any windy swim now.
The Christmas winds were picking up, and the water was choppy enough to make the swim harder work.
Be prepared that most of the coral is dead, though there are still some beautiful sections.
Even in the chop, we saw:
- Barracuda
- Parrotfish
- Blue tang
- A massive school of jacks, which we swam right through
The coral we saw:
- Elkhorn coral
- Brain coral
Snorkeling with a massive school of Jacks at Buck Island
Snorkeling past brain coral at Buck Island
Stop 2: Turtle Beach
Hubby swimming at Turtle Beach at Buck Island
Afterward we sailed to Turtle Beach on the west end, a stretch of soft white sand with turquoise water.
There's no snorkeling off this beach, so this is the time to swim.
A marked trail climbs across the island. The park says it takes about 45 minutes roundtrip at a walking pace and calls it fairly strenuous.
We were too tired after snorkeling and just relaxed on the sand.
Buck Island St. Croix sign
Buck Island Tour Operators
We've only sailed with Llewellyn's, so these tables show what each operator publishes for its own trips.
I've split them into shared trips, priced per adult, and private charters, priced per boat.
Shared Trips
| Operator | Leaves from | Guests | What you get | Per adult |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Wave DancerCaribbean Sea Adventures, 32 ft sailing catamaran |
Green Cay Marina | Up to 16 | 6 hours. Guided trail, a couple of hours at Turtle Beach, optional hike, gear and water. No lunch. Rum punch on the way back. | $125, ages 0 to 17 $105 |
Teroro II42 ft trimaran, sail only |
Green Cay Marina | Up to 24 | 5 hours. About an hour on the snorkel trail, 1.5 to 2 hours at Turtle Beach, gear. Bring your own food and drinks. | $105, kids 11 and under $85 |
Snorkelers in ParadiseCaribbean Sea Adventures, aboard Mile Mark |
Christiansted or Green Cay Marina | Up to 28 | 5 hours. Two guided snorkel stops on the reef, then Turtle Beach. Rum punch on the ride back. | $125, ages 3 to 17 $105 |
CelebrationCaribbean Sea Adventures, power catamaran |
Christiansted | Up to 28 | 3.5 hours. Guided trail, Turtle Beach, gear and water. Rum punch on the ride back. | $95, ages 3 to 17 $75, 0-2 free |
Big Beard's Renegade42 ft sailing catamaran |
Christiansted | Up to 35 | Full day, 9:30 am to 3:30 pm. Turtle Beach, the snorkel trail, then a beach BBQ on St. Croix. | $140, 6-12 $105, 2-5 $32, 0-2 free |
Big Beard's Adventure42 ft power catamaran |
Christiansted | Up to 40 | Half day, 3 to 3.5 hours. Turtle Beach and snorkeling. | $100, 6-12 $75, 2-5 $26, 0-2 free |
Wave Dancer is the one I'd book if we went again.
At 16 guests it's the smallest shared group, and it goes under sail like our trip did. It leaves from Green Cay Marina and includes a couple of hours at Turtle Beach.
Private Charters
| Operator | Leaves from | Guests | What you get | Per boat |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Dragonfly38 ft trimaran, sail only |
Green Cay Marina | Up to 8 | 5 hours. Your own boat under sail, on the Teroro II schedule or your own times | $1,200 ($150 each with 8) |
Smooth RecoveryCaribbean Sea Adventures, 32 ft Boston Whaler (motor) |
Green Cay Marina | Up to 12 | 3 or 5 hours with just your group. The cheapest private charter in its fleet. | $900 for 3 hours or $1,200 for 5, for up to 6, plus $100 per extra guest |
There's no longer a shared trip as small as ours, so a group that wants its own boat has two affordable options.
Dragonfly is the boat most like Llewellyn's. It's a 38-foot trimaran that runs on wind power only, and it's private for up to eight people for $1,200 per boat.
It leaves from Green Cay Marina on the same schedule as its sister boat, Teroro II, or at times that suit your group.
Smooth Recovery is Caribbean Sea Adventures' cheapest private charter.
It's a 32-foot Boston Whaler: $900 for three hours or $1,200 for five, for up to six guests, plus $100 for each extra guest up to 12. You trade the quiet of a sail for a faster ride, and it also leaves from Green Cay Marina.
Prices change by season. Caribbean Sea Adventures and Teroro II both say crew tips aren't included.
How Long a Tour Takes
Half-day trips run about three to four hours. Ours was four, from 9 am to about 1 pm.
Full days run five to six hours and add more beach time, a hike, or lunch, depending on the boat.
Check what a full day includes before you book it. On some boats the extra hours go to the beach or a BBQ, not more time in the water.
Where Tours Leave From
Boats leave from two places:
- Downtown Christiansted, on the boardwalk: Big Beard's and Caribbean Sea Adventures' Celebration and Snorkelers in Paradise.
- Green Cay Marina, about three miles east of Christiansted on Route 82: Teroro II, Dragonfly, Wave Dancer and Smooth Recovery.
Rent a car.
The island is big, and without one you're paying for taxis to the dock and back.
We used Centerline Car Rentals and had a great experience.
From our rental at Cane Bay, Christiansted was about 25 minutes away.
Lunch After Buck Island
Enjoying Ziggy's Famous Cubano after snorkeling at Buck Island
Most shared trips don't include lunch, so plan to eat afterward.
We drove out to Point Udall, then had lunch at Ziggy's Island Market, a gas station on the East End.
They were still cooking a fresh batch of curry when we got there, so I had the Famous Cubano instead. It was good, but I wish I'd tried the curry.
Both are in my list of things to do in St. Croix.
What to Bring
- Reef-safe sunscreen, since Buck Island is a protected reef.
- A sun shirt for the time you're face down on the trail.
- A hat for the boat and beach.
- A travel towel for the ride back.
- Your own mask and snorkel and fins. Every boat provides gear, but the right fit makes a big difference.
- Water and snacks. Our boat had water but no food, so we brought a water bottle and Kind bars.
What I'd Tell a Friend
Go, but pick your day.
Buck Island is a three-mask snorkel, and the wind decides whether it feels like three or two. We went over Christmas, and the Christmas winds made it choppy. If you can, keep your dates flexible and book for a calm morning.
Small boats made our day.
If we went again, we'd book Wave Dancer's shared sail, the smallest shared group.
If you're splitting a boat with family or friends, Dragonfly (sail) and Smooth Recovery (motor) are the most affordable private charters.
Either way, bring snacks, wear a sun shirt, and save room for lunch at Ziggy's.
To see how Buck Island fit into the rest of our week, here's our 8-day St. Croix itinerary, and the rest of the island is in my best things to do in St. Croix.
Hello there!
I am contacting You to find out if I can just pay for a ride to Buck Island without the activities and then stay there. I will be in St Thomas for my birthday next month and would like to travel to Buck Island before heading to St croix the same day. Is this possible just to pay for transportation to the island? I won’t need to come back to St Thomas…Thank you!
Camille
If you want to visit without doing the activities, some of the companies offer private charters. You could contact them directly to see if they would provide transport to visit the island for several hours.
What is the cost for around trip 4 hours to buck island to snorkle?
Thanks for reaching out.
$85 per person in cash, but that was a few years ago so the cost might be higher now.
It doesn’t look like Llewellyn’s website is working anymore, so I’m not sure if they are still in operation. Although the National Park Service (NPS) still lists him as an approved operator as of February 2024.
You may want to either call or email to get an updated cost. When we booked the tour, there was not a way to do it online. We booked over the phone. The NPS lists all the contact information:
NPS Approved Buck Island Operators
Enjoy your trip to St. Croix! Such a beautiful island!