I started wearing sun shirts so I could use less sunscreen around the reefs I swim over. More than a decade later, I've snorkeled 87 sites and I'm down to two brands: Coolibar and Tuga.
Getting here took some bad shirts. The surf-style rash guards I tried from O'Neill and Roxy were either uncomfortably tight or had a neckline that choked me. I couldn't wait to peel it off.
Below is which shirt I reach for, when I switch, what still bugs me about each one, and when you'll want a wetsuit instead.
This post may contain affiliate links. If you purchase through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only recommend places and products I’ve tried myself.
In This Post
My Picks at a Glance
- Most snorkel days: the Coolibar Hightide long sleeve swim shirt. It's my everyday shirt and the one I've worn the longest.
- Long days, several sites, little shade: the Tuga rash guard. It's longer in the back and higher at the neck, so it covers more of me on a long day.
- Men who want a hood to protect the scalp: my husband wears the Coolibar Ocala Swim Hoodie, which Coolibar no longer makes. The Boladeci hooded sun shirt is the closest match I've found.
- Men who skip the hood: the Coolibar Hightide men's swim shirt. My husband wears that one too.
If you're still deciding what makes a rash guard good in the first place (sleeve length, UPF, fabric, fit), I break that down in how to choose a rash guard.
This post is about the two I actually buy.
Coolibar vs. Tuga
| Feature | Coolibar Hightide | Tuga Rash Guard |
|---|---|---|
| I wear it for | Most snorkel sessions | Long days with several sites |
| Look | Solid colors | Prints |
| My size (I'm 5'2") | XS | Small (XS was too tight) |
| Length | Sits right below my hip | Longer in back, down to my lower buttock. About the same as my Coolibar in front |
| Sleeves | Right length on me | A little long on me |
| Thumbholes | No | No |
| Hem | Gripper elastic on the back hem | No gripper |
| Neckline | Crew neck | Sits higher, still not tight |
| Fabric | Aqua Classic: 84% recycled polyester, 16% elastane | 80% nylon, 20% spandex |
| UPF | 50+ | 50+ |
| What bugs me | Still rides up a little at my lower back | The prints on the tops aren't my style |
| What I own | The Hightide in just about every color, plus the Bal Harbour quarter-zip in Navy and Blue Curacao | The Navy/Paisley top |
Coolibar: My Everyday Pick
Wearing my pink Coolibar Hightide rash guard at Angel City in Bonaire
I've been wearing Coolibar sun shirts and leggings for more than a decade, and the Hightide is still the first thing that goes in my snorkel bag.
It's snug enough that it doesn't balloon in the water, but I can still take a deep breath.
The flatlock seams have never rubbed, even after hours face down. And after all those years, none of my Coolibars have faded. The bright colors also help my husband spot me in the water.
My Baja Blue one came with me to the Coral Garden in Tahaa in French Polynesia.
A Teal one came to Anse Georgette in the Seychelles.
Wearing my Coolibar high tide shirt in Baja Blue in Tahaa before snorkeling
The Galapagos is where I was most grateful to be covered.
The sun there was unlike anything I'd felt before, and you walk to the shore sites in full sun, already in your swim gear and carrying your snorkel bag.
I wore my Coolibar quarter-zips for this trip.
At Muelle Tijeretas on San Cristobal, my Blue Curacao quarter-zip and Tuga leggings got me through the 25 minute walk from town with almost no shade.
Then a young sea lion showed up inches from my mask, blowing bubbles.
Concha de Perla on Isabela in the Galapagos surprised me more than any other site on the trip, and we went back four times in five nights.
That's where I wore my navy quarter-zip with my Coolibar navy blue swim leggings.
Wearing my Coolibar quarter-zip shirt in blue curacao to snorkel at Muelle Tijeretas in the Galapagos
What bugs me
The gripper elastic on the back hem helps, but it isn't foolproof. When I'm kicking face down for a long stretch, the shirt still creeps up a little, so I put my favorite reef-safe sunscreen on my lower back every time.
It's shorter in the back than my Tuga. On a long day in full sun, my lower back takes the hit. That's the day I switch to Tuga.
Sizing
I'm 5'2" and wear an XS in both the Coolibar Hightide and the Coolibar Bal Harbour quarter-zip.
The Bal Harbour is very comfortable, but it runs a hair tighter than the Hightide, so I could probably go up to a small in that one.
→ My everyday shirt: Coolibar Hightide
→ The quarter-zip version: Coolibar Bal Harbour
For men: my husband's hooded Coolibar
A not happy sea lion because his nap was interrupted at Muelle Tijeretas in San Cristobal
My husband wears the hooded Coolibar Ocala. He switched to a hood because he needed to start protecting his scalp.
You can see him wearing it at Muelle Tijeretas in the Galapagos in the photo above.
A sea lion napping at the entry was not happy when my husband interrupted its nap getting into the water, and let him know about it.
Hubby wearing his white hooded Coolibar shirt while snorkeling on our sea scooter tour in Moorea
The hood stays put when he pulls his mask on over it, and with a neoprene strap cover the strap glides right over the hood (I explain the strap cover in my snorkel gear guide).
The extra face and neck coverage was a lifesaver on our sea scooter tour in Moorea, and he wore it at Anse Lazio in the Seychelles.
Coolibar no longer makes the Ocala. The closest match I've found is the Boladeci hooded sun shirt: long sleeves, a hood and UPF 50+.
If he skips the hood, he wears the Coolibar Hightide men's swim shirt, which he likes too.
→ Closest to my husband’s hoodie: Boladeci Hooded Sun Shirt
→ His everyday shirt: Coolibar Hightide
Tuga: My Long Day Pick
Wearing a Tuga rash guard right before snorkeling the Blue Lagoon in Rangiroa
When I know I'll be in the water most of the day, I grab my Tuga rash guard instead.
My Coolibar stops right below my hip.
My Tuga is about the same length in front, but in back it comes down to my lower buttock, so I get better coverage.
Showing the rash guard length difference between Coolibar and Tuga snorkeling shirts
Shirts ride up when you're stretched flat on the surface, and that strip of lower back is easy to burn. The neckline sits higher too, without the choking feeling I got from O'Neill and Roxy.
My Tuga Navy/Paisley top and matching Tuga leggings came on our Blue Lagoon tour in Rangiroa (pictured below).
Tuga was also my pick for 2 to 3 sites a day in Bonaire and the four stops on our Curieuse Island snorkeling tour in the Seychelles.
Hubby wearing his Coolibar hooded shirt and me wearing my Tuga sun shirt while snorkeling the Blue Lagoon in Rangiroa
What bugs me
The prints. The patterns on Tuga's tops aren't my style. I love the sportier prints on their swim leggings (I have them in the Peaceful Hawaii color and black) and wish the tops looked more like them.
The sleeves run a little long on me, but I'm only 5'2".
Sizing
I wear a small in Tuga. The XS was too tight, and the small fits slightly looser than my XS Coolibar.
→ My long-day shirt: Tuga Rash Guard
→ For men: Tuga Rash Guard
Do You Need a Wetsuit?
Wearing my Ripcurl shorty wetsuit
Usually not. We've snorkeled the Caribbean, the Maldives, Belize, Thailand and French Polynesia, and never needed one.
A long sleeve rash guard and swim leggings have always been enough.
I've worn a wetsuit twice: at the Great Barrier Reef, and on one Galapagos tour.
We went to the Galapagos in early May and were fine at the shore sites, but we were told the water was warmer than normal.
The only time I wore one in the Galapagos was on the Kicker Rock 360 tour, where the tour provided shorties. Kicker Rock is open ocean and runs cooler than the shore sites, so I wore one over my rash guard for that stop and was happy to have it.
I bought a Rip Curl shorty wetsuit before that trip, and I really like it. I left it at home in the end, because the Kicker Rock tour provided one and the free shore snorkels were warm enough without it.
I also had to watch every pound for the tiny plane from San Cristobal to Isabela, where your checked bag and carry-on share one weight allowance, so a wetsuit I didn’t need wasn’t coming.
If you get cold easily, or you're going to the Galapagos between June and November (the cooler months, when people mention needing one), consider packing one.
A rash guard won't keep you warm on its own.
Don't Forget Your Hands
Wearing my snorkel gloves during our sea scooter tour in Moorea
On our two-week French Polynesia trip, we snorkeled every day. I used reef-safe sunscreen and my hands still burned.
My sun kissed hands (why I wear snorkel gloves)
Neither my Coolibar nor my Tuga has thumbholes, so nothing on either shirt covers the backs of my hands.
Now I don't snorkel a long day without gloves. I started with fingerless fishing gloves, and these days I wear Coolibar's fingerless sun gloves.
My fingers stay free to adjust my mask and work my underwater camera, and the backs of my hands stay covered.
→ What I wear on my hands: Coolibar Fingerless Sun Gloves
What I'd Tell a Friend
Buy a long sleeve shirt, not a short sleeve one, and put the extra money toward fit. If a shirt chokes your neck or rides up your back, you’ll stop wearing it because you will be constantly adjusting.
If you're buying one shirt, buy the Coolibar Hightide. It's what I wear most.
If you burn easily, snorkel several sites a day, buy the Tuga instead, or add it as your second shirt.
If your scalp burns, get a hooded shirt.
Either way, keep sunscreen on your lower back. No shirt I've owned covers it all day.
0 Comments