Sint Maarten vs. Saint Martin: Which Side Should You Stay On?

by Nichole | Last updated Nov 19, 2026 | St. Martin

Sint Maarten and Saint Martin are one island split between two countries. Sint Maarten is the Dutch side, Saint Martin is the French side, and you can drive from one to the other without showing a passport.

My husband and I have stayed on the French side twice, both times at the same small hotel in Cul de Sac. We've driven all over the Dutch side too, for snorkeling, a rum run in Philipsburg and plane-watching at Maho Beach, but we've always gone back to the French side to sleep.

So this is a French-side fan's take, with a fair case for the Dutch side and who should book it.

This post may contain affiliate links. If you purchase through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only recommend places and products I’ve tried myself.

In This Post

The Short Answer

  • Stay on the French side if food is a big part of your trip, you like quieter beaches, and you'd pick a small hotel or villa over a resort. Plan on renting a car.
  • Stay on the Dutch side if you want casinos and nightlife, a large resort with lots on site, or a short drive from the main airport and the cruise port.
  • Either way, you'll spend time on both. From our hotel on the French side, Grand Case and Orient Bay were about 10 minutes away, and the airport was 30 to 45 minutes.

Is Sint Maarten the Same as Saint Martin?

Sint Maarten vs Saint Martin Map

Sint Maarten vs Saint Martin Map

Yes, Sint Maarten and Saint Martin are the same island.

The northern part, Saint-Martin, belongs to France. The southern part, Sint Maarten, is its own country within the Kingdom of the Netherlands.

There's no passport control between the two sides.

You still need a passport to fly in, and everyone lands on the Dutch side: Princess Juliana International Airport (SXM) is there, and so is the cruise terminal in Philipsburg.

Where We Stayed and Why We Went Back

Karibuni Boutique Hotel in St Martin

Karibuni Boutique Hotel in St. Martin

Both times, we booked Karibuni Boutique Hotel in Cul de Sac, on the French side's northeast coast.

It's tiny, six suites and two villas, on a hill facing Pinel Island. Our suite had its own plunge pool.

Breakfast showed up at our deck about 30 minutes after we raised a wooden fish to signal the staff, and the hotel's boat ran us across to its restaurant on Pinel Island, where chairs and an umbrella came with the stay.

We went back because of the people.

Before one trip, I reached out to ask whether the suites had an ice tray so we could make cocktails on the deck. By the time we arrived, they had put an ice machine in our suite.

Sylvana, who brought our breakfast each morning, always greeted us with a warm smile.

Add a quiet, gated hillside and VIP treatment on Pinel Island, and we didn't see a reason to look anywhere else.

Which Side Has the Better Food?

lobster pappardelle at Coco Beach in St. Martin

Lobster pappardelle at Coco Beach in St. Martin

Bottom Line: The French side has the better food, and for us it isn't close.

The breakfast pastries at Karibuni came from The Express by Bacchus, and we later went to the bakery ourselves several times.

French grocery stores stock imported cheeses, pâtés and charcuterie.

At GrapeWine in Hope Estate, I spotted a bottle from Egly-Ouriet, one of our favorite grower Champagne producers, and a staff member named Alain walked us through a rhum agricole tasting.

A few nights, dinner was a fresh baguette, French cheese and a glass of Champagne on our deck.

When we went out, Grand Case's Restaurant Row was the draw. At Le Cottage, the rich and flavorful lobster cream soup came wrapped in puff pastry.

We still haven't eaten at one of Grand Case's lolos, the open-air barbecue stands serving local Caribbean food. They're on our list.

The Dutch side has a wider spread of cuisines and more chain restaurants, which can help if you're traveling with picky eaters.

Which Side Has the Better Beaches?

Drinking Champagne at Karibuni Restaurant on Pinel Island St Martin

Drinking Champagne on the beach at Pinel Island St. Martin

Bottom Line: The French side has the better beaches for us.

Every one of our favorite beaches is on the French side:

  • Pinel Island, a five-minute boat ride off Cul de Sac. Go early. On our Christmas trip, we had our pick of front-row chairs at 9:15 am, and the beach was packed by 11.
  • Orient Bay, the island's busiest beach, lined with beach clubs. We booked a lunch table in the sand at Coco Beach and ordered the lobster pappardelle.
  • Grand Case, best at sunset from the end of the pier near Quai 58.

We drove to Baie Rouge planning to snorkel but found the waves too rough. Topless sunbathing is common on French-side beaches, and the south end of Orient Bay is the island's official clothing-optional beach.

The Dutch side has no official nude beaches, though Cupecoy has a long-running reputation as an unofficial one. If you'd rather not see it, check before you pick a beach on either side.

On the Dutch side, Maho Beach was the highlight of our day trip. We loved sitting on the sand while jets came in to land just over our heads.

Watch from the sand, not the airport fence. The jet blast from departing planes is strong enough to knock people off their feet (and killed a tourist holding on to the fence in 2017), which is why the warning signs are there.

Divi Little Bay was calm and easy for swimming when we snorkeled there.

Which Side Has the Better Nightlife?

Bottom Line: The Dutch side has the nightlife.

All of the island's casinos are there, and most of the bars and clubs are around Simpson Bay, Maho and Philipsburg.

On the French side, dinner was our night out. Grand Case and Orient Bay have bars, and some Orient Bay beach clubs host parties, but there are no casinos, and on our trips things got quiet after dinner.

We liked that. If late nights matter to you, stay Dutch.

Which Side Has the Better Hotels?

Incredible French breakfast at Karibuni Hotel on St. Martin_ croissants, meats, cheeses

Incredible French breakfast at Karibuni Hotel on St. Martin

Bottom Line: The French side is better for small hotels and villas, and the Dutch side is better for big resorts and points hotels.

The French side leans small: boutique hotels, guesthouses and villas.

Before we picked Karibuni, we also looked at Orient Bay (walk to the beach clubs), Grand Case (walk to dinner) and Terres Basses (large private villas and the resort La Samanna). 

The Dutch side has more of the large resorts and condo buildings, many right on the beach, and more of the big hotel brands if you're booking with points.

The one we know a little is Divi Little Bay Beach Resort, because we snorkeled off its beach.

Which Side Has the Better Shopping?

Purchasing rum and rhum while in St Martin

Purchasing rum and rhum while in St. Martin

Bottom Line: The Dutch side is better for duty-free shopping, and the French side is better for food and wine shopping.

Front Street in Philipsburg is lined with duty-free jewelry, perfume and electronics shops.

Our stop was Gulmohar's (also called Whisky Paradise), a liquor store with rums and whiskies we don't see at home. The owner told us some customers show up with an empty suitcase just to fill it. We left with Foursquare from Barbados, our favorite rum distillery!

On the French side, GrapeWine covers wine, rum and picnic supplies. At Tijon in Grand Case, we took a fun perfume-making class and bottled our own scent to take home.

It's on my list of favorite things to do in St. Martin.

Which Side Has Better Outdoor Activities?

Kayaking near Pinel Island in St Martin

Hubby and I kayaking near Pinel Island in St. Martin

Bottom Line: The French side has more of the hiking and kayaking we like. Neither side is great for snorkeling.

Here are some of our favorite outdoor activities on the French side:

  • Pic Paradis, the island's highest point. The hike starts at Loterie Farm, about a 15-minute drive from Karibuni, and we saw a family of monkeys near the end. Here's our Pic Paradis trail guide.
  • Sentier des Froussards, a coastal trail from Anse Marcel past Petites Cayes and Grandes Cayes. It took us about 3.5 hours at an easy pace. Start early, because the heat builds fast.
  • Kayaking from Cul de Sac to the sandbar and Petite Clef, then on to Pinel Island if you have the energy.

Pinel Island got three masks in my St. Martin snorkeling guide, and Petite Clef got two.

Tintamarre, a small island off the French side that you reach by boat tour, gets recommended a lot. We haven't been.

On the Dutch side, we snorkeled at Divi Little Bay over a sunken airplane, helicopter and submarine, another three-mask site. Rainforest Adventures runs the Flying Dutchman, which it bills as the world's steepest zip line. We might try it on our next visit.

If turtles are what you're after, add Saba. It's a 12-minute flight from SXM, and our boat snorkel there with Sea Saba was full of turtles.

Our St. Martin and Saba itinerary shows how we split the trip.

Money, Language and Getting Around

Our car rental from Kennys Car Rental in Sint Maarten

Our car rental from Kennys Car Rental in Sint Maarten (photo taken at Divi Little Bay)

Money

The French side uses the euro.

The Dutch side's official currency is the Caribbean guilder. Prices though are often listed in dollars and dollars work at most businesses. Dollars are accepted on the French side too.

We paid by credit card almost everywhere. Use a card with no foreign transaction fees, and check which currency the card machine is charging you in.

Language

French is the main language on the French side. We knew about two words of French, bonjour and merci beaucoup, and still got by at grocery stores and restaurants, where staff spoke some English.

English is the everyday language on the Dutch side.

Getting around

If you stay on the French side, rent a car. We rented one both trips with Kenny’s Car Rental. Excellent service!

When the Dutch Side Makes More Sense

Philipsburg in Sint Maarten

Philipsburg in Sint Maarten

The Dutch side is the better fit if:

  • You're on a cruise. Ships dock in Philipsburg, next to Front Street.
  • Your trip is short or your flight times are tight, and you want to be near the airport.
  • You want casinos or bars after dinner.
  • You want a big resort with several pools and restaurants on site, or you're using hotel points.
  • You don't want to rent a car.

What I'd Tell a Friend

Stay on the French side, rent a small car, and give the Dutch side one full day.

Ours went like this: snorkel at Divi Little Bay late in the morning, rum shopping on Front Street after that, then Maho Beach in the afternoon to watch the planes come in. We drove back to Grand Case for dinner at Le Cottage.

Skip the French side if you want nightlife, a big resort, or a trip without a rental car.

And don't come to St. Martin for the snorkeling alone. Come for the food and the beaches, and swim when you can.

Meet Nichole

Meet Nichole

Think of me as your geeky, discerning travel friend who dives deep (Google Page 20 and travel forums deep!) to find what’s really worth your vacation days.

My husband and I have explored 36 countries, from African safaris and 87 snorkel sites to boutique hotels and the world’s great wine regions. We both work full time, so every vacation day counts. From $2 street tacos to Michelin-starred dinners, we’re always chasing what’s worth the money.

If this sounds like you, subscribe below!

12 Comments

  1. Napoleon A Tolbert

    Excellent reading through all the information about both places. I am excited to visit one day.

    Reply
    • Nichole

      Thanks for reaching out. It really is a beautiful and unique island because of the two different personalities. We enjoyed exploring both sides. Hope you can visit soon.

      Reply
  2. mark mennen

    Friends of ours invited us to come for a week or ten days. I would love to go but my wife has very little interest in this place I think. She has to get more information before she can make some plans.

    Reply
    • Nichole

      My husband and I loved Saint Martin, but it all depends on what type of traveler you are and what your ideal vacation looks like.

      I am happy to answer any questions about our experience. 😊

      Reply
  3. Amanda Fawver

    Thank you for sharing your expertise. We would like to travel to the island and are debating on which part of the island to stay on as we will be traveling with our kids (8 and 11). Do you have recommendations for hotels/resorts on Sint Maarten? I am interested in the hotels on Orient Beach you recommended.

    Reply
    • Nichole

      We always stay on the French side, so I haven’t stayed in any of the hotels on Sint Maarten.

      Divi Little Bay Beach Resort seems to get a lot of love from the TripAdvisor community as being a great family-friendly hotel on Sint Maarten.

      I haven’t stayed at Divi, but my husband and I did snorkel off the resort’s beach over a sunken helicopter and airplane. We also saw an eel, a turtle, and some tropical fish. Nice beach and calm water.

      Reply
  4. JE

    You said no nudity on the Dutch beaches, does that include going topless? I would figure both sides being European topless on the beach would be acceptable.

    Reply
    • Nichole

      Yes, that includes topless. If a local disagrees, please correct me if I’m wrong. Now, I’m sure it probably happens time to time.

      For example, my husband and I love going to Bonaire, another Dutch island. Again, no nudity, but there was a lady topless on a very secluded beach (which I will not disclose to protect that privacy). No one else was around but her and us. This beach was off-the-beaten path where tourists rarely visit.

      If you enjoy being topless, Baie Rouge and Orient Bay are beautiful beaches where it is well accepted.

      Reply
  5. karen knoth

    Want to live on the French side in a small two bed for two people with two cats year round not expensive

    Reply
    • Nichole

      Living on St. Martin sounds wonderful. I could definitely get used to having warm weather year round. I would suggest reaching out to a St. Martin realtor with your search requirements to see what properties are available.

      Reply
  6. Paulo Santos

    Plane spotting: Maho Beach Sint Maarten

    ‘nough said.

    Reply
    • Nichole

      That is certainly a unique experience! We loved watching the planes breeze by our heads while sitting on the beach. Makes for some great photos!

      Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Hi, I'm Nichole!

Snorkeling with sharks one day, a Michelin meal the next. I share first-hand guides to rated snorkel spots, African safaris, charming boutique hotels, and wine travel to help discerning travelers plan trips worth taking.

Enriching Pursuits Ladybug Logo

Sound like you?

Then you'll love my latest on:

  • Boutique Stays: charm and warm service
  • Sip & Savor: wine getaways & foodie finds
  • Outdoor Pursuits: snorkeling, hikes, bike trails
  • Nichole Pro Tips: save smart, splurge wisely