If you've landed here, you probably have the World's 50 Best Bars list open in another tab and you're wondering which Mexico City names deserve one of your few nights.
We've used that list to plan bar nights on a lot of trips: Jigger & Pony in Singapore, Tres Monos in Buenos Aires, Sip & Guzzle in New York, and Little Red Door in Paris, where we showed up right at opening just to get seats at the bar.
We love a well-made cocktail that someone has put a lot of thought into. So in Mexico City, we booked the famous ones.
The rankings and our ratings didn't line up.
When we went, Baltra Bar was the lowest ranked of the four Mexico City bars on the World's 50 Best list, at No. 45. It was our favorite bar of the trip.
Handshake Speakeasy was No. 3 that year and No. 1 in the world the next. It landed in the bottom two of our ratings.
Here are the five bars my husband and I went to in one week, rated on the drinks, the ambiance and the service.
For each one I've listed what we ordered, how to get in, and how its ranking has moved since we went.
This post may contain affiliate links. If you purchase through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only recommend places and products I’ve tried myself.
In This Post
The Short Version
- Our favorite: Baltra Bar in Condesa. Small, relaxed, and the most original drinks we had all week. Go on a Tuesday for Martini Tuesday.
- Best show behind the bar: Hanky Panky in Juarez. You walk in through a little taco shop. Reserve ahead.
- Best for mezcal: Tlecan in Roma Norte. Mostly standing room and walk-in only, so go early.
- The biggest name: Handshake Speakeasy in Juarez. Excellent drinks, cooler service.
- The liveliest room: Licoreria Limantour in Roma Norte. Grab a seat at the bar.
Cocktail Bar Rating Key
🍸 🍸 🍸 = Ultimate trifecta: exceptional and unique cocktails, inviting ambiance, and attentive warm service
🍸 🍸 = Well-crafted cocktails but lacking in either ambiance or service or both
🍸 = Decent cocktails but not a repeater
1. Baltra Bar
Old George Sour at Baltra Bar in Mexico City
Rating: 🍸 🍸 🍸
Baltra was our first night in Mexico City, and we almost skipped it.
We'd landed that afternoon, eaten our way through Tacos Don Juan and El Pescadito in the same neighborhood, and we were wiped out.
I'm so glad we pushed through the travel fog. Baltra became our favorite bar of the trip and the one I'd go back to first (and again and again).
It's small and unpretentious. Service was super friendly, the room was cozy, and the drinks were the most unusual we had all week.
They were almost as inventive as the cocktails at Selva, which made my list of the best things to do in Oaxaca.
You can sit at the bar, in a little lounge with a sofa and chairs, or outside. We sank into one of the couches and stayed for a slow, quiet evening.
The bar is named after Baltra in the Galapagos, and the whole theme follows Darwin's voyages there.
That one hit home for us: we flew out of the Baltra airport at the end of our trip snorkeling the Galapagos.
Baltra comes from the team behind Licoreria Limantour, with bar director José Luis León overseeing the menus at both.
We went on a Wednesday, so we missed Martini Tuesday, the weekly night when a lot of the city's bartenders show up for martinis.
If your dates allow, that's the night to go.
What we ordered:
→ Old George Sour (Patrón Silver tequila, basil, cucumber, cardamom, absinthe, egg white)
→ Opium (San Cosme mezcal, celery bitters, lime juice)
Book: OpenTable
2. Hanky Panky
Transatlantico Fizz at Hanky Panky Cocktail Bar in Mexico City
Rating: 🍸 🍸 🍸
Juarez | No. 22 on the World's 50 Best Bars when we went | Not on either 50 Best list for 2026
Hanky Panky has some of the best showmanship behind a bar I've ever seen. I loved watching the bartenders mix drinks from side to side.
The drinks matched the show: unique, elaborate and well balanced.
Getting in is half the fun. You enter through a small taco shop, and you leave through... I won't ruin it.
Inside, your eye goes straight to the bright neon sign that says "We are Hanky Panky." You can sit at the bar on red leather stools or at the tables along the wall.
Walter Meyenberg opened Hanky Panky in 2016 as a private bar for his friends. It later became members-only, and now anyone can book.
When we went, the menu was a passport. You picked a country and got a drink built around its flavors, with a flavor profile listed at the bottom to help you choose.
The menu changes with the seasons, so yours will probably look different.
I thought Hanky Panky deserved a higher spot than No. 22. Instead it has dropped off both the World's and North America's 50 Best lists for 2026.
It's still on my short list of favorite cocktail bars anywhere, along with Mori Bar in Tokyo and The Old Man in Hong Kong.
What we ordered:
→ Tiger Punch (coconut milk punch with Ron Matusalem Gran Reserva 15, Disaronno amaretto, black tea, black pepper, red pepper, cardamom, cloves, curry, lemongrass, turmeric, ginger and lemon peel)
→ Transatlantico Fizz (Martin Miller's gin, Lustau manzanilla sherry, Grand Marnier, orange juice, egg white, grapefruit soda)
Book: OpenTable
3. Tlecan
The Tascalate Sour at Tlecan in Mexico City
Tlecan is the coolest mezcal cocktail bar we found, run by some incredible bartenders.
It wasn't on the World's 50 Best list when we went.
A year later it was No. 20 in the world, and it's now No. 5 in North America.
A friendly bouncer led us in.
Walking through the door feels like stepping into a pre-Hispanic tomb: lots of geometric shapes, monochrome terra cotta colors, and regional music in the background.
There are only a few stools, and most of the space is standing room. We stood near the bar so we could watch the bartenders work.
Our server was first class, knew the drinks inside and out, and guided every choice we made.
Tlecan builds its cocktails around Mexican ingredients and small-batch mezcals.
The downside is space. If you want to sit down for a long night, this isn't your bar.
We walked right in at 7 pm on a Saturday, back before Tlecan made the 50 Best list.
It still doesn't take reservations, and recent visitors describe a line and a waiting area down the street on busy nights. Go early.
What we ordered:
→ Tascalate Sour (mezcal, tascalate from Chiapas, fermented cocoa, lemon juice, agave syrup, egg white)
→ Pulque Colada (natural pulque, pineapple milk punch, coconut water, espadín mezcal fat-washed with coconut oil)
Book: No reservations
4. Licoreria Limantour
Jamaica Mezcal at Licoreria Limantour in Mexico City
Rating: 🍸 🍸
Maybe we shouldn't have gone to Baltra first, because our expectations were sky high by the time we got here.
Limantour opened in 2011, and 50 Best credits it with starting Mexico City's craft cocktail scene.
It's much bigger than Baltra, spread over two levels plus a terrace.
If you want a more personal night, sit at the bar so you can talk with the bartender. That's where Limantour shined for us.
We didn't love the cocktails as much as Baltra's, but our bartender gave us the warmest hospitality of the whole trip.
A few things have changed since we went.
Co-founder Benjamin Padrón left in 2024, and José Luis León still runs the bar program.
There's also a second Limantour in Polanco. We went to the Roma Norte original.
What we ordered:
→ Jamaica Mezcal (Los Siete Misterios Doba-Yej mezcal, hibiscus syrup, cardamom, lime juice)
→ Vicuña (Ojo de Tigre mezcal, Chilean pisco, smoked pineapple juice)
Book: OpenTable
5. Handshake Speakeasy
Cariño at Handshake Speakeasy in Mexico City
Rating: 🍸 🍸
Handshake was the other bar where our expectations were through the roof.
It opened in 2019 and was named the best bar in the world just several years later.
Dutch bartender Eric van Beek leads it, and his Cariño won the 2018 Bacardi Legacy global cocktail competition.
The entrance is easy to miss. Look for door No. 13 at Amberes 65.
Once you're inside, the whole staff greets you with a loud "¡bienvenido!" Recent reviews say they still do it.
The room was dark and cozy with an Art Deco feel and a grand chandelier as the centerpiece.
You can sit at a high-top table, at the bar, or in the cozy chairs around the edge of the room. We were seated at the high-top in the middle.
I always recommend the bar so you can watch the bartenders work.
Handshake has since expanded to two levels, so the room you get may not be the one we sat in.
I liked that the menu lists tasting notes for each drink. The Matcha Yuzu was bitter and herbal, while the Once Upon in Oaxaca was fresh and smoky.
The drinks lived up to the ranking. The service was professional, but it wasn't close to the warmth we got at Baltra and Limantour, and that's what cost it the third glass.
What we ordered:
→ Matcha Yuzu (Toki whisky, matcha, yuzu, vanilla, whey)
→ Cariño (Bacardi 8 rum, yellow Chartreuse, vanilla, lemon, Greek yogurt, nutmeg)
I really wanted the Be An Original (Michter's bourbon, sesame, tawny port and mole), but they were out of mole. Darn.
Book: OpenTable
Five Bars in One Week
We fit all five into one week by putting each bar right before or after a meal nearby.
The full day-by-day plan is in my 7-day Mexico City itinerary, but here's how the bar nights worked:
- Baltra: 6:15 pm on arrival day, right after tacos in Condesa.
- Handshake: 7 pm, after a full day walking Centro.
- Tlecan: 7 pm on Saturday, after a bottle of Mexican wine on our hotel rooftop.
- Hanky Panky: 5 pm on Sunday, then dinner at Contramar at 7.
- Limantour: 6:30 pm Monday, after a lunch at Pujol that ran until 5, then dinner at Rosetta.
We stayed at Casa Izeba in Roma Norte and felt comfortable walking around the neighborhood at night.
We took an Uber back from Baltra, Handshake and Hanky Panky because of the later hour.
What I'd Tell a Friend
Don't pick your nights by the number next to the name.
The bar we loved most was the lowest ranked on the list when we went, and the No. 3 bar in the world landed in our bottom two.
Every bar on this list made good drinks.
Baltra is the one that felt like a place we'd go back to every night.
The lists also move fast. Tlecan went from unranked to No. 5 in North America, and Hanky Panky fell off both lists after we went.
Mexico City still had three bars in the 2026 World's 50 Best top 50, so the city is not short on options.
Book what you can before you fly, show up early at Tlecan, and sit at the bar wherever you can get a seat.
¡Salud!
0 Comments